As the Founder of Kinflow, a DEI consultant, and a TEDx Speaker, Adriana Morvaiova's passion lies in empowering individuals and communities to transform conflict into connection.
Here, Adriana explores diversity fatigue for Sync NI and explores why sometimes, it can even inadvertantly create new divides.
Diversity Fatigue: When Inclusion Efforts Exclude
Diversity fatigue is a growing phenomenon within organizations, referring to the feeling of exhaustion or cynicism that employees experience when DEI initiatives either lack effectiveness or, in some cases, inadvertently create new divides. Initially, this fatigue was noted among minority employees bearing the weight of diversity work; however, it increasingly applies to employees who feel that DEI efforts ignore or undervalue their perspectives and contributions.
This is a significant concern given that UK organizations spent approximately £8 billion on DEI-related initiatives in 2023, a figure projected to grow by 20 per cent annually as companies continue to prioritize these efforts. In Northern Ireland, DEI initiatives are essential in addressing not only race and gender but also cultural and religious identities unique to the region’s social landscape. However, without a nuanced approach, DEI efforts can end up alienating employees, creating skepticism toward DEI spending, and missing opportunities for meaningful impact.
READ MORE: Rob McConnell, Head of Expleo NI, on staff engagement and 'finding the right balance'
The Financial Landscape of DEI in the UK and Northern Ireland
With billions of pounds allocated to DEI annually, organizations have begun to scrutinize whether these programs yield a substantial return on investment. Studies indicate that when DEI programs are improperly designed or lack clear goals, the outcomes can be disappointing. In the UK, for example, research reveals that nearly 40 per cent of DEI programs fail to achieve their intended outcomes. With annual DEI budgets ranging between £100,000 and £1 million for large organizations, this translates into significant financial waste. In Northern Ireland, where workplaces often contend with deep-seated cultural complexities, the challenge is even more pronounced, necessitating a strategic approach to maximize effectiveness and prevent diversity fatigue.
The financial implications of ineffective DEI efforts are not limited to wasted resources. In the UK, companies that don’t implement DEI initiatives effectively risk increased employee turnover, reduced engagement, and reputational damage, each of which adds hidden costs. When employees view DEI as mere “box-ticking” rather than genuine change, they may disengage, with studies suggesting disengagement can cost organizations up to 34 per cent of an employee's annual salary in lost productivity. For DEI programs to succeed, they must resonate with all employees. However, recent studies in the UK show that 52 per cent of employees feel DEI initiatives overlook the economic concerns that matter most to them.
READ MORE: Emma Grossmith - While remote workers may be out of sight, they shouldn’t be out of mind
Key factors contributing to diversity fatigue in DEI programs include:
1. Ineffective communication - In Northern Ireland, cultural and religious differences play a significant role in social dynamics. When DEI messaging lacks sensitivity to these contexts, employees may feel that their identities and experiences are overlooked, leading to disengagement.
2. Lack of measurable goals - Without clear, measurable objectives, DEI initiatives are difficult to evaluate, leading to frustration among employees who perceive these programs as surface-level efforts.
3. Overemphasis on group identities - By focusing heavily on group categories, DEI programs may unintentionally create a sense of division rather than inclusion, leading employees to feel that their individual contributions are minimized.
Inclusion exclusion in practice - US elections
At the heart of DEI initiatives is a commitment to inclusivity, yet these efforts can sometimes inadvertently exclude certain groups. The perception of “identity politics” can overshadow the real purpose of DEI programs. For instance, overly focused identity-based campaigns can lead people to feel like they’re being evaluated based on their demographic characteristics rather than their qualifications or contributions. This speaks to point three on group identities.
This was a major criticism directed at Vice President Kamala Harris’s recent campaign, where opponents argued that her DEI-focused platform emphasized identity at the expense of addressing economic and practical issues. The overemphasis on representation, for some voters, began to feel more like tokenism than genuine inclusion.
How to address diversity fatigue?
1. Shift from identity first to strengths-first DEI - Rather than focusing solely on identities, DEI programs can embrace a "strengths-first" approach, spotlighting each individual’s unique skills and contributions.
2. Integrate economic inclusivity into DEI - Integrating economic inclusivity like background, career growth, and financial well-bein into DEI goals, ensures fair benefits for all employees, addressing concerns of those who may feel overlooked by identity-focused efforts.
3. Develop DEI ambassadors focused on bridge-building - DEI ambassadors should serve as bridge-builders rather than representatives of specific identities.
By incorporating these creative approaches, DEI programs can evolve to address the nuanced needs of modern workplaces, particularly in complex environments like the UK and Northern Ireland.
Read Sync NI's free online Big Data Belfast autumn magazine here.
